Inside the Menu
At Garcia's Pizza In A Pan, the menu offers a cozy mix of hearty pizzas, fresh salads, and comforting pasta dishes, all designed to satisfy a variety of cravings without overwhelming the choices. Most people start by picking the type of pizza they want—whether it’s a deep dish or a thinner pan style—then often add some classic sides like breadsticks with your choice of dips. For lighter options, the salads range from simple garden greens to more filling choices with bacon or chef’s ingredients. If you’re in the mood for pasta, there’s a family-sized spaghetti bucket with different sauce options to keep things interesting. The menu flows well for groups or individuals, making it easy to combine dishes for a full, balanced meal, whether you’re dining in or ordering delivery.
Menu Sections (33)
-
Garden Salad – $2.49
-
Spinach & Bacon – $3.39
-
Chef Salad – $3.99
-
Double Cheese – $2.99
-
Pepperoni – $3.25
-
Sausage – $3.25
-
Gutbuster – our famous 3/4 pound slice with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers and onion. – $3.75
-
Custom Slice – a slice the way you want it! your choice of up to five goodies (it takes 15 minutes, but it's worth the wait). – $3.99
-
Baby Stuffed Pizza – available for lunch, goodies change daily. the big stuffed pizza taste for one. – $4.29
-
Cheese
-
Cheese - Each Goodie
-
Gutbuster
-
Cheese
-
Cheese - Each Goodie
-
Gutbuster
-
Cheese
-
Cheese - Each Goodie
-
Gutbuster
-
Fabulous Feast – save up to $4.20! a large thin pan pizza with two goodies, a large garden salad or 1/2 dozen breadsticks, and 1/2 gallon of soft drink or get a large thick pan pizza for only $2.00 more! – $19.99
-
Flying Feast – any pizza slice, a garden salad and a medium soft drink. – $6.69
-
Slice Special – any pizza slice, breadsticks and a medium soft drink. – $5.99
-
Salad Special – a garden salad, breadsticks and a medium soft drink. – $5.39
-
Cookie Combo – any pizza slice, medium soft drink and two cookies. – $5.74
-
Marinara Sauce
-
Meat Sauce
-
Alfredo Sauce – with broccoli add small $0.49, regular $0.79, with grilled chicken small $0.79, regular $1.19.
-
Marinara – $9.99
-
Meat Sauce – $10.99
-
Alfredo Sauce – with broccoli plus $1.49 & with grilled chicken plus $2.69. – $11.49
-
Breadsticks (2) – with one dip. – $1.79
-
Breadsticks (6) – with two dips, your choice of garlic butter, spicy tomato or nacho cheese sauce. – $4.29
-
One Cookie – $0.59
-
Three Cookies – $1.49
Popular Dishes at Garcia's Pizza In A Pan
How This Menu Feels
Dining at Garcia’s Pizza In A Pan feels like a comforting blend of nostalgia and ease. Whether you’re grabbing a quick, satisfying meal on your own or sharing generous plates with friends, the menu invites a relaxed, unhurried pace that lets you savor every bite. There’s a warmth in every dish, a reminder of tradition and care that gently slows the day. The atmosphere encourages quiet moments or lively conversations, making it perfect for solo dinners or casual gatherings. Here, the food isn’t just a meal—it’s a familiar, heartfelt experience that lingers long after the last slice is gone.
When to Visit
- Monday
- Tuesday
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Saturday
- Sunday
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:30 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:30 PM
- 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM